Lilly’s advertises seasonal menus, which are always posted
on their website,
but also has specials available in addition to the menu. The specials for this night were Grilled
Swordfish Steak served over grilled polenta with an olive tapenade and sautéed
broccoli ($27) and Prime Rib, served with potato and vegetable of the day
(steamed broccoli). The Queen cut was $18 and the King cut was $24.
While we were reviewing our menus, the waitress arrived to
take our drink orders. We didn’t stray
from the usual and ordered a Malibu & Diet Coke and a Long Island Iced
Tea. A basket with dinner rolls, both
white and wheat, arrived at our table and our water glasses were filled by the
busboy. I grabbed a dinner roll and am always disappointed when I find only
cold, hard, foil-wrapped butter available. Whipped butter or dipping oil would
have made the dinner rolls much more enjoyable, especially in such a nice
restaurant. Regardless, I ate a wheat roll while reviewing the menu.
Although the specials sounded great, we opted to order from
the menu. I chose the Pan Seared Salmon ($20) served with a roasted corn salsa,
fingerling potatoes, grilled asparagus and topped with cilantro-lime cream
sauce. My husband ordered the Herb Crusted Pork Tenderloin ($17). The menu
described his pork as a grilled herb crusted pork tenderloin with roasted
fingerling potatoes, and grilled endive finished with a cranberry mustard demi
glaze. We both also ordered a half house salad ($4). (Many of the salads and entrees were
available in either the half or full serving, which is great if you have a smaller
appetite.) Although they had several salad dressings available to choose from,
they did not have French dressing, which was my husband’s first choice. He chose his second choice, Thousand Island
and I chose Blue Cheese.
House Salad |
The salads arrived and had a nice selection of mixed greens
served with grape tomatoes, onions, cucumbers, shredded carrots, pepperocini’s
and black olives. My dressing, served in a small pitcher on the side, was sort
of “peppery”, which you wouldn’t expect from Blue Cheese. The dressing wasn’t bad, just different.
While we waited for our meals, I took a look around the
restaurant. The dining room was almost empty when we arrived but since it was a
beautiful evening, several parties opted for the outdoor patio seating, or the Sunset Terrace as they call it, which
was filled with guests. We were seated
by the back window with a beautiful view of the greens and we were even able to
catch a few golfers finishing up their game. There is an adjoining bar that
appeared to be for members only and was filled with people that were apparently
enjoying a cocktail after playing 18 holes!
The noise level was tolerable and likely would have been drowned out if
the dining room was filled with guests. Overall, I would consider the setting
to be on the quiet side, making for a relaxing evening.
Just before our meals arrived, the waitress stopped by to
ask if we needed another drink – a second drink for both of us, please!
Pan Seared Salmon |
Our plates arrived and the food looked delicious. My salmon was cooked perfectly and the
cilantro-lime cream sauce added just the right amount of flavor. While I was
expecting the roasted corn salsa to be warm, it was actually a cold salsa with
a hint of jalapeño making this a refreshing accompaniment to the rich salmon. The potatoes and asparagus
were “ typical” – nothing fancy but they rounded out the meal.
My husband loved his pork tenderloin, which was prepared to
medium doneness and drizzed with the cranberry mustard demi glaze. He commented that one of his potatoes was
hard - as if it was not cooked long enough. He feared that they were all under-cooked but the rest
were just fine. He even ate a few of mine
since my salmon filled me up (or was it the bread? or the salad that filled me
up?).
Chocolate Fudge Cake |
The waitress knew that we had both gift certificates (we mentioned this to her when we were seated) so she
added up the bill for us before finalizing it. The bill was $71 – just shy of
the $75 requirement. Should we use the $25 gift certificate or splurge and buy
dessert to reach the $75? After hearing
the three dessert options (Irish Mousse Cake, Turtle Cheesecake and Chocolate
Fudge Layer Cake), we opted for dessert and ordered the Chocolate Fudge Layer
Cake ($7.95) ala mode ($1.50). The
fudge topping on the cake was rich and creamy but the cake itself was a bit on
the dry side. My husband didn’t complain and ate it up – noting that Chocolate Cake
and Vanilla Ice Cream was one of his all-time favorites. Score one for Lilly’s !! (Or should I say they got a “hole in one”?).
While it may seem that we splurged on this meal (total cost
with tax and gratuity was $99.17), once you subtract the Restaurant.com gift
certificate value of $50, our total was $49.17. The gift certificate had
originally cost me only $8 – making the grand total for the evening $57.17,
which is right in-line with our average spending.
As you know, I still have a $25 Restaurant.com gift
certificate to use so we’ll be back to visit Lilly’s sometime soon.